1. US
  2. Bayville
  3. Mill Creek Tavern
  4. Mill Creek Tavern

Mill Creek Tavern

(on bayville avenue)
American Restaurants in Bayville, NY
American Restaurants
Bars
Restaurants

Contact Us

Make a call
516-628-2000

Website

Hours

Tuesday
4:30PM - 9:00PM
Wednesday
4:30PM - 9:00PM
Thursday
4:30PM - 9:00PM
Friday
4:30PM - 10:00PM
Saturday
4:30PM - 10:00PM
Sunday
4:00PM - 9:00PM

Menu

Starters
Onion Soup Au Gratin
Gruyere crouton
$6.95
Tavern Market Salad
Baby greens, garden vegetables choice of dressing
$6.95
House Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, caesar dressing, parmesan crouton
$6.95
Baby Field Green Salad
Dried cranberries, candied walnuts, maytag bleu cheese, balsamic vinaigrette
$7.95
Iceberg Wedge
Warm bacon, red onion, chopped tomato, blue cheese dressing
$7.95
Arugula Salad
Roasted beets, goat cheese, toasted almonds, raspberry vinaigrette
$8.95
Burrata Mozzarella
Creamy mozzarella, balsamic reduction, basil infused olive oil, grape tomatoes
$9.95
Chilled Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
Bloody mary cocktail sauce
$14.95
Mim’s Classic Chicken Wings
Hot sauce, bleu cheese dressing, celery
$9.95
Pretzel Baked Brie
Brie stuffed pretzel, brown sugar, fig jam
$8.95
Three Cheese Spinach & Artichoke Fondue
Tri colored tortilla chips
$11.95
Tuscan Calamari
Fried calamari, tuscan peppers, marinara, lemon horseradish aioli
$11.95
Crispy Chili Pop Shrimp
Baby shrimp, sweet thai chili sauce
$10.95
Baked Little Neck Clams Oreganata
Roasted garlic, white wine, olive oil, parmesan bread crumbs
$9.95
Blackened Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled red onions, roasted red peppers, spinach, mozzarella, sour cream, salsa
$11.95
Spicy Ahi Tuna Martini
Ahi tuna, mango salsa, spicy mayo, wakame, crispy wonton
$13.95
Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls
Vermont cheddar, bleu cheese, scallions, hot sauce
$10.95
Escargot a la Provence
Fresh herb garlic butter, white wine
$11.95
Main Plate Salads
Tavern Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine, caesar dressing, parmesan, crouton
$11.95
Tuscan Grilled Vegetable Salad
Zucchini, asparagus, artichoke hearts, roasted tomatoes, portobello mushrooms, goat cheese, baby greens, stone mustard vinaigrette
$13.95
Grilled Salmon Salad
Portobello mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, grilled asparagus, toasted pine nuts, roasted red peppers, arugula, balsamic vinaigrette
$17.95
Grilled Steak Salad
Gorgonzola, crispy onions, roasted tomatoes, baby spinach stone mustard vinaigrette
$17.95
Chopped Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken, tomato, red onion, bacon, cucumber, maytag bleu, cheddar, sliced egg, mixed greens, bleu cheese dressing
$15.95
Tavern Mussel Pots
Mussels Fra Diavlo
Spicy pomodoro
$15.95
Mussels Au Vin Blanc
White wine, fresh herb lemon garlic butter
$15.95
Mussels Provencale
Tomato, garlic, onion, white wine, butter, olives, toasted bread crumbs
$15.95
Mussels Casino
Shallots, garlic, butter, roasted red pepper, bacon, white wine
$15.95
Sandwiches
Grilled 10 oz. Prime Angus Burger
Exclusive blend, brioche bun, american, cheddar, swiss, bleu cheese, mozzarella, bacon, mushrooms, sauteed onions $1.00 each
$12.95
Baja Fish Tacos
Grilled or blackened shaved cabbage, mango salsa, queso fresco, cilantro lime crema
$13.95
Chicken Ciabatta
Grilled or milanese chicken, baby arugula, roasted red peppers, prosciutto, fresh mozzarella & balsamic glaze
$13.95
Grilled Steak Sandwich
Skirt steak, crispy onions, melted mozzarella, luger sauce, garlic bread
$17.95
Grilled Shrimp BLT Wrap
Grilled shrimp, applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo
$16.95
Main
Linguini Seafood
Jumbo shrimp, mussels, calamari, scallops, white wine garlic olive oil or fra diavlo
$23.95
Rigatoni & Blackened Skirt Steak
Spinach, grilled portobello mushrooms, gorgonzola, porcini mushroom sage cream sauce
$19.95
Hickory Smoked BBQ Baby Back Ribs
Choice of side
$24.95
Lemon Sole Oreganata
Jumbo shrimp, mussels, tomatoes, sauteed spinach, roasted garlic lemon olive oil, angel hair
$24.95
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Shrimp & asparagus risotto, shaved granna, white truffle oil
$27.95
Stone Mustard Grilled Salmon
Warm grilled vegetables, goat cheese, stone mustard glaze
$24.95
Mama’s Homemade Chicken Pot Pie
Roasted chicken breast, carrots, peas, potatoes, fresh sage bechamel sauce, puff pastry crust
$16.95
Zucchini Linguini
Baby shrimp, roasted tomato white wine garlic broth
$24.95
Grilled Montauk Swordfish
Lemon oregano olive oil, pancetta, roasted red peppers, garlic broccoli rabe, roasted potatoes
$26.95
Apricot Glazed Salmon
Arugula salad, almonds, goat cheese, red wine vinaigrette
$24.95
Sauerbraten Short Ribs
Mustard herb spatzle, braised red cabbage
$25.95
Chicken Granny Smith Apples
Grilled sweet potatoes, candied walnuts, hudson valley cider riesling sauce
$22.95
Sauteed Chicken
Diced roma tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, toasted pine nuts, lemon scampi olive oil, parmesan roasted potatoes
$22.95
Chicken Parmigiana
Linguini, tomato basil sauce
$19.95
Jager Schnitzel
Pork cutlet, warm german potato salad, mushroom gravy
$22.95
Pecan Crusted Sole
Vanilla scented whipped sweet potato, cranberry orange compote, sauteed zucchini
$23.95
Sesame Seared Ahi Tuna
Seared rare, wasabi cream, soy ginger, wakame, toasted coconut sticky rice
$26.95
M.C.T Homemade Macaroni & Cheese
Cheddar cheese, american cheese, fresh cream, baked buttered bread crumbs
$15.95
Mim’s Meat Loaf
Crispy onions, country gravy, vegetable medley, mashed potatoes
$16.95
Eggplant Parmigiana
Ricotta cheese ravioli vodka sauce
$17.95
Classic Linguini White Clam Sauce
Little neck clams, roasted garlic, white wine, oregano olive oil
$17.95
Chop House Selection
16 oz USDA Prime NY Sirloin
$34.95
18 oz Cowboy Bone in Rib Eye
$36.95
Chicken Breast
$18.95
Marinated Skirt Steak
$26.95
8 oz Filet Mignon
$35.95
Market Fish Selection
Ahi Tuna
$27.95
Salmon
$24.95
Jumbo Shrimp
$26.95
Lemon Sole
$23.95
Sea Scallops
$27.95
Special Nights At Mill Creek Tavern
Lotsa Pasta Night
Tuesday
$14.95
Wine Down Wednesday 1/2 Price Bottles
Wednesday
$14.95
Fajita Night
Thursdays
$16.95
Live Music
Friday
$16.95
Early Evening Pre Fixe
Every night
$24.95
Sides
Roasted Potatoes
Baked potato
$5.00
Mashed Potatoes - Sweet Potato Fries
$5.00
Tavern Fries - Grilled Sweet Potatoes
$5.00
Whipped Sweet Potato
$5.00
Asparagu
Sauteed broccoli $1.95
$5.00
Creamed Spinach
Mixed vegetables
$5.00
Sauteed Spinach
Mac & cheese
$5.00
Shrimp Risotto
Add $1.95
$5.00

Location

275 Bayville Avenue
Bayville, NY
11709

About

Long Island's most popular neighborhood restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern serves seasonal robustly flavored, American cuisine in a relaxed setting of casual elegance. We offer a full dinner menu with daily specials in the dining room and the bar. Behind the bar, an outstanding wine list, local micro-brews and a large selection of hand-crafted specialty cocktails are offered. Private parties, large groups & special events are welcome, with private dining & event space available. Mill Creek Tavern is known for welcoming guests with excellent value and warm hospitality. We also have an off-premise catering division called Mill Creek Catering & Events. From pig roasts and lobster bakes to formal weddings. We look forward to seeing you soon. Cheers - Rich

Photos

Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo Mill Creek Tavern Photo

Latest Mill Creek Tavern Reviews (Average Rating: 4.5)

based on 222 review(s)

Great good, friendly staff, generous portions. We like their daily specials for takeout.

Eric S. May 29, 2022 via Yelp

Lately have been ordering takeout. Never disappointed ! My favorite steak sandwich is so yummy ! Hoping to come back to dining in very soon. I love the...

Madeline M. January 22, 2022 via Yelp

We were visiting family in Mill neck and choose Mill Creek Tavern because they have a very nice menu. I like that they print the daily specials with...

Richard S. March 31, 2022 via Yelp

Latest

Thinking of hosting an event? Mill Creek is the perfect venue. Inside or outside. We are ultra Covid compliant for parties and 50 or less. Come celebrate with us. #covidcompliant #events #millcreek #showers #birtdayparty🎉
#wewillneverforget #911memorial
The kids are back in school (or remote learning) and there’s a lot on everyone’s plate, so why not enjoy a delicious meal cooked by our chefs and savor the last bit of nice weather? Book your table on opentable we’ll see you soon! #millcreekny #millcreektavern #bayville #localrestaurants #eatlocal #dontcooktonight #thekidsarebackinschool #outdoordininglongisland
You haven’t lived until you’ve tried our homemade Buffalo Chicken Spring Rolls. They’re a customer favorite for a reason! #millcreek #millcreektavern #millcreekny #localrestaurant #bayville #bayvillerestaurants
Come Join the team!!!
Savor the last days of summer with our Blueberry Mojitos! Available in 16oz or 32oz... #millcreek #millcreekny #millcreektavern #bayville #bayvillerestaurant #blueberrymojito🍹
Stop by @millcreek.ny this weekend and try some of our Oktoberfest menu items. What’s the wurst that can happen? (We think you’ll like it! 😉) #millcreek #millcreektavern #millcreek💙syou #bayvillerestaurants #oktoberfest #oktoberfest2020 #authenticgermanfood
Oktoberfest is finally here at Mill Creek! We know you look forward to our authentic German menu every year, and this year we did not disappoint! Enjoy your favorite with one of our seasonal draft beers! #millcreek #millcreektavern #millcreekny #bayvillerestaurants #bayvilleeats #oktoberfest2020 #rindergoulash
It may not be the south of France, but it sure will feel like it! Reserve your table under our professionally heated 🔥 semi open air tent! Reservations can be made on @opentable or visit our website! Link in bio 😉 #millcreek #millcreekny #millcreektavern #bayvillerestaurants #heatedtent🔥 #outdoorseating #bayvillestrong #covidcompliantbusiness
We want to thank our guests for their ongoing support as we continue to navigate through our new normal! Stop down and enjoy a home cooked meal with us tonight! Visit our website to see our daily deals and new menu items. Sign up for our email list and get 20% off your online order! Link in bio! #millcreek #millcreektavern #bayville #bayvillerestaurants #supportlocalrestaurants #orderonlinenow
Veterans, we are thankful today and everyday for your service. We honor all those who have served our country, past and present. #millcreek #millcreektavern #veteransday #thankyouforyourservice
Have you tried our Chicken with Granny Smith apples grilled sweet potatoes walnuts in a cider Riesling sauce? If that doesn’t say fall we don’t know what does. # millcreektavern #yummyfood #fallfoods🍃🍁🍂 #bayvilleny #happyfood
Going out to dinner doesn’t mean you have to throw away your New Years Resolutions! We’ve got plenty of healthy options available, plus daily dinner specials. Zucchini Linguine pictured with baby shrimp, or swap it out for any other protein! #millcreek #millcreektavern #dailyspecials #plantbasedoptions #newyearsresolution2021 #familyrestaurant #bayville #zucchininoodles
Wishing all of our customers, friends, neighbors & staff a Happy New Year... #millcreek #millcreekny #millcreektavern #bayvillestrong #bayvillerestaurants #thankyou #happynewyear #goodbye2020
Merry Christmas from our family to yours! #millcreek #millcreektavern #merrychtistmas #happyholidays
Take a break from the holiday hustle and come in for dinner & drinks! Have a seat at the bar and warm up by our toasty fireplace... #millcreek #millcreektavern #millcreekny #holidaycheer #holidayspirit #dinnerndrinks #dinner #appetizers #drinks
Trays for the Holidays! Don’t feel like cooking? Order Trays to Go from Mill Creek! To view our full menu, visit our website, link in bio! #millcreek #millcreektavern #traystogo #traysfortheholidays #bayvillerestaurants #bayville #happyholidays #merrychristmas #happyhannukah #familyrestaurant
The holiday season is always cozy @millcreek.ny and this year we all could use a good meal and some holiday cheer! We have spots left for Christmas Eve! Book your table on @opentable #millcreek #millcreekny #happyholidays #holidaycheer #bayvillerestaurants #bayville #christmaseve #familyrestaurant #goodfood

Information

Company name
Mill Creek Tavern
Category
American Restaurants
Est
2008

FAQs

  • What is the phone number for Mill Creek Tavern in Bayville NY?
    You can reach them at: 516-628-2000. It’s best to call Mill Creek Tavern during business hours.
  • What is the address for Mill Creek Tavern on bayville avenue in Bayville?
    Mill Creek Tavern is located at this address: 275 Bayville Avenue Bayville, NY 11709.
  • What are Mill Creek Tavern(Bayville, NY) store hours?
    Mill Creek Tavern store hours are as follows: Tue-Thu: 4:30PM - 9:00PM, Fri-Sat: 4:30PM - 10:00PM, Sun: 4:00PM - 9:00PM.
  • Does Mill Creek Tavern(Bayville, NY) have a menu with prices?
    Yes, Mill Creek Tavern has online menu! Here you can see full menu with latest prices.

Nearby

Del's Bar & Grill
129 Pine Hollow Rd., Oyster Bay 3.4 miles